Should against Would

Giganews Newsgroups
Subject: Should against Would
Posted by:  Dmitry Yagnyatinskiy (dimapump…
Date: Mon, 11 May 2015

Me and Anton Shepelev were arguing how to ask a girl correctly: "Would you like sex with two guys?" or "Should you like sex with two guys?"
As far as I know, "Would" is ok and correct, but Anton insists on "Should". He points on a former times. Is that right that in Classical King's English, for example of 19th century, "Should" is the only way in such a sentence?

Mr. Pumpov